Same thing happened to me. I just placed an order last night and got an email this morning requesting I send over a copy of my CC and ID. I was told I could block out the middle 8 digits of my cards so that's what I did. Sent it back over to Justin and now waiting for the outcome.
So far I've seen nothing but honest and positive energy from this forum so I don't suspect there's any funny business going on.
I mean for Pete's sake, it speaks volumes when the owner/administrator and head moderator personally responds to your questions. That would be like Mark Zuckerberg replying to your concerns and questions about your Facebook account, which is NEVER going to happen.
If Dylan say's he'd personally take care of you if there's any problems then I'd say you're good to go!